INSURING THE HEARTLAND SINCE 1879 ®
Congratulations to our 2026 Preferred Agencies!
Twenty-four Buckeye Insurance Group partner agencies have earned the honor of being named a 2026 Preferred Agency. In addition to achieving retention and growth benchmarks, these agencies demonstrate exceptional insurance knowledge and service to their policyholders. We are grateful for your partnership and congratulate you on this honor!
Thanks,
John Brooks, President and CEO
Premier
- Ahlers Haworth Agency (Vandalia, Ohio)
- Billing Insurance Agency Inc. (Anna & Oxford, Ohio)
- Bixler Insurance Inc. (Geneva, Berne, Decatur, & Portland, Indiana)
- Excel Insurance Services Inc (Huntington & Fort Wayne, Indiana)
- Fort Recovery Insurance Agency Inc. (Fort Recovery, Ohio)
- Fouts, Davidson, Burks Agency LLC (Delphos, Beloit, Jewell, & Washington, Kansas)
- Francis J. Paulus Ins. Agency Inc. (Woodsfield, Ohio)
- John Wood Insurance Agency, Inc. (Georgetown, Owensville, Peebles, & West Union, Ohio)
- Kathrens Insurance Agency (Bowling Green, Ohio)
- Koverman Staley Dickerson Insurance (Troy, Piqua, Covington, New Carlisle, & Tipp City, Ohio)
- Littman-Thomas Agency, Inc. (Greenville, Bradford, & Troy, Ohio)
- Miami Valley Insurance Agency (Covington, Ohio)
- Porter-Spears & Bundy Insurance Agency Inc. (Ottawa, Kansas)
- Reed & Baur Insurance Agency LLC (Athens, Pomeroy, & Logan, Ohio)
- Stahl Stoller Meyer Insurance Center (Paulding, Ohio)
- Strong’s Insurance (Kingman & El Dorado, Kansas)
- Tyner Insurance Group Inc. (Council Grove, Wamego & Emporia, Kansas)
- Willis Murphy Advantage Insurance Agency (Eaton, OH)
Ambassador
- Burgett Insurance Agency Inc. (Killbuck, Ohio)
Diplomat
- Bieker Insurance Agency, Inc. (Hays, Kansas)
- Bradley Insurance Agency of Ohio (Ravenna, OH)
- Fey Bruder Insurance Advisors (Oxford, Ohio)
- Grant County Insurance Agency Inc. (Ulysses, Kansas)
- TWI Insurance Services, Inc. (Wakeeney, Kansas)
Enjoy peace of mind relying on the experience and stability of a company you can trust.
Find Your Local Buckeye Insurance Group Agent!
Buckeye Insurance Group partners with independent agents across Ohio, Indiana, and Kansas. These agents are experts in Buckeye’s products and are focused on delivering the best service to our policyholders.